

And a lot of those responses boiled down to the fact that Phyllis is now no better than Diane. She’d just be a tragic victim!īut there were also a whole lot of pretty darn vocal noes. Shift the blame away from Phyllis and there’d be nothing to forgive. Because she wouldn’t even be at fault! “She should just say Jeremy drugged her to make it look like he killed her so he and Diane could go away together. More: Time is flying for Michael Graziadei and his little onesĬindy Ciresi Longo said “Yes,” but then offered a plot to make sure folks wouldn’t have to forgive Phyllis.

She should be forgiven but she should also get some help for her obsession with Diane.” I think she could almost claim that she was temporarily insane for what she did. Stark is the one who fed the hate with his idea to frame Diane, knowing that Phyllis was desperate to get rid of her. “She teamed up with a man who talked her into doing his dirty work for him. “Phyllis was blinded by hate for Diane to the point that it literally drove her over the edge,” she wrote. Some viewers, like Bobbie Malsch Poor, were full of empathy for the redhead. “Victor and Chloe were forgiven, why shouldn’t she be? A lot of people in Genoa City have done a lot of things and were forgiven.” Actually, we’re pretty sure a lot of people in Genoa City have faked their own deaths, not just Victor and Chloe! And when put that way, Phyllis’ forgiveness seems like a given. Phyllis has been a main character for decades, so we get it, it’s hard to turn on her. If we were hoping for a clear winner in this argument, we were sorely mistaken, but with over 400 responses and counting, we definitely stirred up some feelings! There were, we’ll admit a lot of yeses. So naturally, we decided to turn to the fans and ask on Facebook whether Phyllis should be forgiven for faking her own death. We didn’t come to a consensus, but let’s just say that the feelings ran strong. We here at got into a bit of a spirited debate over who was the worse mom: Phyllis or Diane.

And that’s when things got even worse as she dumped the whole thing on her daughter to figure out what to do!

But she backtracked on that almost immediately and revealed herself to Summer. Daytime Emmy Winners: Our Dream Picks For Outstanding Achievement in Pot-Stirring, Stair Sex and Pine-Cone-Related Decision-Makingįirst, Phyllis decided that faking her own death and disappearing forever to frame Diane would be the smart move.
